Manga 108725 Youkoso Jitsuryoku Shijou Shugi No Kyoushitsu E %e2%88%9ahorikita Reviews Filter Check 3

Did you like Classroom of the Elite? Yes? Well, did you like Horikita? Also yeah? Well guess what! You still shouldn’t read this.

There was no reason for me to read this, it was literally on hold for 2 weeks until I said “screw it let's get it over with.” I ended up wasting my time, I would rather make a sandwich instead.

This is a “what if?” As described by the description on MAL. Even then it’s not that big of a difference or anything to really be called a what if. When it comes to a what if you want it to really grab ... your attention and get you saying, “huh, what if that did happen?” That’s how a what if should get you hooked. But essentially this isn’t interesting. It’s also useless because why do we need this?

It’s supposed to focus more on the relationship between Horikita and Ayanokōji. That’s not really important or that big of a what if. As a matter of fact this has the romance tag even though nothing happens between these two, it’s just Horikita really acting out of character; which just isn’t right to see. I’m pretty sure even the author was thinking to themselves, “Why am I doing this?”
They gave up during the end because what the heck kind of ending are you supposed to give this?

Let me tell you something about the art, that’s the one thing this manga has got going for it. The art is fine and not totally insulting or anything. That’s all.

No one asked for this. Literally no one. This is not one of those cases where it’s “the hero we never knew we needed.” Instead it’s more like “this is a mistake, can we take it back?” No you can't, it's forever stuck here and now we have to suffer the consequences.

Don’t waste your time reading this if you’re a big Classroom of the Elite fan, of course I can’t tell you what to do. But I can try and stop you and warn you. I wouldn’t recommend this to anyone.

YouJitsu, but with slightly more fanservice and much less point.

While reading this, I wasn’t able to find out reason why should I even keep reading it. Sure, short spin-offs like this are usually inferior to the main story and are more of a bonus for fans, but still. For a “romcom” alternative take, the romance falls flat, and definitely out of character – and not in a good way. For comedy, there is suspiciously low amount of jokes - and no amount of funny ones. Being a “what if”, it does not expand on the characters, as practically those aren’t the characters you know, those ... are different personalities with same name and look. And to repeat, not in an entertaining way.

At least the art is okay, nothing extraordinary, but also nothing unpleasant to the eye.

I don’t think I would have liked this even if I liked the original story. The search for reason to read this ended up unsuccessfully.