Imagine Oregairu with shittier writing and a 10th of the artistic and animation quality. That’s Yumemiru. Whether or not that appeals to you really depends on how much you like the witty/psycho-social analysis style of romcom.
This was truly a difficult one for me to rate because on one hand, I did actually enjoy the show for the most part. It started slow, but picked up after a few episodes and had some genuinely interesting social scenarios in which the MC found himself needing to help other people. But it’s frustrating because it squandered a lot of potential, was poorly paced and focused on some ... characters who ended up not even really mattering in the end.
The show is unapologetically inspired by Oregairu, even the OP is a direct parallel to Oregairu’s OP, literal frame for frame at some points. Wataru does feel like a poor man’s Hachiman and a lot of the archetypes from Oregairu are present in this story. It’s also got the same approach of someone who’s shut himself off from the world gradually opening up and learning about people by helping them with their own problems. Even though I hated Oregairu, I still recognise that it was objectively a very well written story. That same quality isn’t present here. At least, not in the anime.
So, in order to really explain what I mean by some of my criticisms I’ll have to give a very brief summation of the plot. You can read the MAL summary, but I’ll put it in simpler English. Loser essentially begs a girl to go out with him every day for a few months in middle school, gets rejected every time and they eventually settle as friends. They get to high school and he still pursues her but eventually she has a change of heart and starts liking him. Why? Well, your guess is as good as mine after reading that summary and I watched the damn anime. So yea, that’s the type of writing we’re working with here.
It wasn’t all bad though. Surprisingly, the other characters are actually pretty well written. The supporting girls are all better than the main girl, which is typical for me in romance shows, but it’s particularly pronounced in this. Now, I have been told that this isn’t as big a gap in the LN as it is in the anime, but I can only evaluate the show since I haven’t read yet. And in this, I could not for the life of me understand why the MC is into the FMC.
She’s abrasive, rude, self centred and really only shows interest in him when it seems like he stopped liking her. They did try to give us a “boo hoo my life was so sad so that’s why I’m a tsundere asshole” spill with the FMC, but again it just didn’t add up to the type of behaviour that she displays IMO. She just doesn’t get the sort of development she needs to get the audience to care.
Now as I said, the other girls are solid. They range from ok to legit waifu contenders(Shinomiya and Fuuka) I enjoyed seeing the MC help them with various issues they went thru over the course of the show which led to his development as well. That’s actually probably my favourite part of the show. We do see the MC make legitimate strides to better himself and by the end of the show he’s a solid dude. Each problem he solves feels realistic and has a tangible effect on him.
The other main issue I have with the show is the art and animation. The character designs are extremely generic, they’re basically the 2017-2023 anime design starter packs. From what I’ve seen of the LN art they really don’t do these characters any justice. There’s a few moments that are supposed to be somewhat serious that just don’t hit for me because of the lack of expressiveness from the character models. I’m not saying it has to be ufotable, but damn, I should at least be able to sense some sort of emotion coming from the characters.
Despite my criticisms of the series, I did enjoy stretches of it. It starts slow but really picks up once a few side characters are introduced and there’s some really enjoyable moments in this anime. If you can look past the shoddy animation and inconsistent pacing at the start, you’ll find a decent watch with a decently written main character. By the end of the show I was pretty excited for its release on Mondays, so yea, it’s a tricky one. I’d say give it a shot and see how you like it. It has some interesting ideas and I think it has the bones of a decent story.
Yumemiru gets 7 out of 10
Alternative Titles Japanese: 夢見る男子は現実主義者 Information Type: TV Episodes: 12 Status: Finished Airing Aired: Jul 4, 2023 to Sep 19, 2023 Premiered: Summer 2023 Broadcast: Tuesdays at 02:00 (JST) Licensors: Sentai Filmworks Source: Light novel Theme: School Duration: 23 min. per ep. Rating: PG-13 - Teens 13 or older Statistics Score: 6.631 (scored by 71,329 users) 1 indicates a . Ranked: #60712 2 based on the top anime page. Please note that 'Not yet aired' and 'R18+' titles are excluded. Popularity: #1527 Members: 152,042 Favorites: 959 Available AtResources | ReviewsSep 18, 2023 Imagine Oregairu with shittier writing and a 10th of the artistic and animation quality. That’s Yumemiru. Whether or not that appeals to you really depends on how much you like the witty/psycho-social analysis style of romcom. This was truly a difficult one for me to rate because on one hand, I did actually enjoy the show for the most part. It started slow, but picked up after a few episodes and had some genuinely interesting social scenarios in which the MC found himself needing to help other people. But it’s frustrating because it squandered a lot of potential, was poorly paced and focused on some ... Aug 7, 2023 First review (6 episodes) This show is getting a lot of flack for no reason. Sure it's not the "OreGairu of this season" that I've seen it referred to, but in terms of casual watching rom-coms, it's pretty decent. There's this guy who's madly in love with a girl for all but 5 minutes before deciding it's a terrible idea and basically following his life. The characters are all enjoyable with none being annoying, it goes at a good enough pace, and nothing cringey. It has a good senpai, good sister, good friends - all of the classic trope characters are there. It has a similar ... Aug 26, 2023 While the season isn't over, I've seen enough to give a decently reflective review. The anime starts strong, with the protagonist chasing his main love interest. After realising how much trouble he gives her. he then learns to take a step back. This allow her breathing room to make new friends, but both of them are still unsatisfied as she's still not aware of her feelings towards our protagonist, and he doesn't allow himself to pursue anything with her. The season starts to go off into mediocrity after this, with each episode or so introducing a new female character for the main character to befriend and tease ... Aug 15, 2023 After watching the first episode I thought it all sat oddly with me. The conversations and events did not go the way you normally expect them to. It was just kind of weird and off. I was going to chalk it up to bad writing, or inaccurate translation, or poor execution, but thought I should look at the next episode or two and wound up looking at all that have been simulcast on Hidive so far. What got me thinking to look at it some more was a certain kind of consistency of tone in the personalities and in the things that were being said ... Oct 5, 2023 This had SO much potential, but ended up going into so many tangents that it ultimately became boring. The main character becomes involved (not romantically) with a bunch of different girls, that it's almost like THAT'S the actual plot of the anime - him helping out a bunch of random-ass girls to figure things out, see things from a guy's perspective, and/or self-improve. Meanwhile, the actual story we came here for gets put on a hiatus until the last 2 episodes. I'll give them props for actually having a SOMEWHAT decent ending, because to be honest, I was half-expecting them to completely screw us out of ... Sep 18, 2023 Yelp, one of my most anticipated shows of the season, seemingly spat on with some of the worst animation in the history of forever. Nah, it ain't so dramatic...or is it? Some say that this is the "OreGairu of the season", but honestly, I beg to differ. That said, novelist Okemaru's Yumemiru Danshi wa Genjitsushugisha a.k.a The Dreaming Boy Is a Realist is a fairly known work to some in the know, and if you get the chance to read the LN, it's a really nice work that may sound like the typical cliche rom-com at first, but I promise you that the story changes little ... Jan 9, 2024 It reached 4 stars because I found the change in the MC's attitude at the beginning very interesting and peculiar. An anime with a lot of potential but which unfortunately remains static, unchanged, as if afraid to give a definitive answer to the questions of those who watch it. The main character had many chances with secondary characters, or so it would seem as the author continues to maintain a fine balance between romantic interest and respect by deceiving with tactical blushes. The "final" answer amounted to a handshake like contact, dropping the whole thing into behaviors that again can be misunderstood, let's say that the mix between ... Nov 22, 2023 This anime is a poor man's version of OreGairu, but it started with such a promising premise. The main character, the eponymous dreaming boy who became a realist, decided to stop simping for a girl so nakedly because it was weirding her out and made him out to be a total creep, so he will just simp from a far. This was a great move from him, because it allows him to interact with more people and develop as a more complete person instead of simping the girl for the entirety of high school. However, this anime sabotages itself with the generic animation and uninspired ... Jan 19, 2024 Simple how to enjoy(?) review: Yumemiru is clearly inspired from an oregairu. I view this a lighthearted and kinda waterdowned version of it. Hachiman-esque mc and the fmc is a slightly unbearable tsundere. There is also many other girls in this anime. PLEASE DO NOT WATCH THIS AS A ROMANCE ANIME!!! If you are thinking about watching this anime and want to enjoy it, try not to look at this as a romance anime. If you come in with expectations of romance you will be greatly disappointed. Yumemiru become much more enjoyable when you think of this as a coming-of-age/mental(?) of the mc. Similar to hachiman, mc goes ... Oct 9, 2023 Honestly it is overall a good, meh-ish show you get what I mean ? Like the mc carried this show on his back LITERALLY. Aside from his damn terrible taste in women he’s a pretty solid guy. I SERIOUSLY don’t understand why the hell is the female MC even the female MC, like the other side girls are bettter written and wayy more likeable. I don’t think anyone likes the female mc, she isn’t even given much emphasis in a lot of the episodes her only point of being relevant is that the mc likes her FOR NO REASON. Like some characters are top waifu material ... Apr 8, 2024 To put it into one sentence, this anime is just a bunch of common anime characters traits (that we've seen everywhere already), interacting with each other in a really nice and comforting kind of way. The way these stereotypical anime characters interact with each other lights up a little fire in my heart. It's nothing complicated or anything, but that simplicity makes this a nice little anime. For me personally, the anime is also somewhat relatable and has some nice moments to it. Talking comedy wise the anime is kind of stupid, but in a kind of funny way. Sadly, the characters is literally just anime tropes ... Sep 20, 2023 As someone who’s read the Web novel, manga, and Light Novel for this series, I have to say this is the best adaptation by far. However while I do “enjoy” reading it, this is definitely a story that was suited for the faster pace of an anime, and that’s the main reason why I don’t like the Manga or LN. In case anyone is wondering, the anime differs greatly from the source material. One such difference is the main event of the last episode should have instead taken place somewhere around episode 6 and occurred very differently in the original story. I think this ... Oct 3, 2023 First thing I noticed since the first episode, is that the animation is amateur. Maybe the animation company is relatively new and makes its first steps into making anime, or the budget wasn't so flexible, so many scenes feel a bit awkward. The music was sometimes too loud or out of place, and the background also poorly decided. Nevertheless, they did their best in putting up a cute anime together, and I enjoyed how the relationships of the characters developed, even if each scene very expected. You can tell they tried hard. The scenes at the bookstore had a very nice atmosphere and the introduction of a ... Sep 19, 2023 Short answer. Honestly speaking its not that bad Long asnwer is. The ending is exacly what you expect to happen. And honestly the anime made it so HARD to root for the main characters, that i really had a mixed enjoyment i truly hopped for a diffrent ending which made me stick out with it. Idk disapointing thats all i shall say. I mean if the ending was diffrent i truly would have maybe even given a 6/10 or 7/10 if the building actually mattered and something interesting happend. Characters Mid Litteral filler Wolrd building Mid Nothing interesting Ending Mid Boring and are exacly what you expected Music Ehh ... Sep 18, 2023 if you into some anime with romcom school setting and from light novel adaptation, maybe this series its worth to try. this is long version, caused MAL forced me to write long paragraph. I agree with mixed feelings and not recomended series after 3 episode, this anime not giving audience a good strong first impression. And if you anti tsundere Female Lead, I suggest you to avoid this series, this FL is typical tsundere type girl to the max. but despite her flaw, i kinda understand why she act like that. the story its predictable but i kinda enjoyed and its head on nail with my ... Aug 1, 2023 I feel this show would be a lot more enjoyable if not for the most hard to understand main girl I have ever seen. Usually my complaints about characters in a romance anime stem from the mc, since they tend to be really annoying when it comes to actually confessing. The mc in this show, however, is actually kind of alright. For once he isn’t in the wrong. The main girl, Natsukawa, had been persistently followed by our main guy, who would constantly profess his love for her, until one day, after a close encounter with a football, our mc decides that actually it’s lame ... Aug 6, 2023 This is a show for the romance anime lovers, but not for many beyond that. There is definitely an oppertunity for viewers to relate to the characters if they have ever felt like a burden towards someone they loved or cared about. The sections of this review are written in order of their significance to the overall viewing experience. Characters: This anime focuses on its main duo (Natsukawa and Sajo), and most other characters appear to be used for gags or minor plot points. Despite this, there is potential for some characters to be expanded upon if given more screen time in future. The main duo ... Aug 20, 2023 OP is a straight up Oreigaru copy. Also this anime was definitely influenced by Oreigaru and maybe Seishun Buta Yarou. Maybe the LN wasn't, from what I gathered, but the directors were. Since I read the manga first, though there aren't many chapters available, I had high expectations to this series. But this is a joke. If you think the idea is interesting, read the manga. It's 100x better. I haven't read the LN, so I can't comment on that. But every monologue that makes the character dynamics interesting has been removed. And even worse, the pacing is atrocious, what is even going on here? How many ... Sep 19, 2023 As a reader of the light novel I was a little excited about this, I even liked the first chapter, but everything else was even more boring than the light novel and that's saying a lot. The plot was very slow, the only good chapters were that Mina was the main center because of the rest Aika being the heroine was very stressful. The designs were pretty cute for my taste, but the OP and ED were fucking bad and unfunny. Mina, Sasaki-san and Wataru were my favorite characters, the rest were pure garbage, especially Aika. I wouldn't recommend the series even to a hater. May 17, 2024 The anime presents a classic romantic comedy plot with a twist, focusing on unrequited love and a protagonist who is refreshingly aware of his feelings. Initially, it promises a deep phycological exploration of relationships, akin to shows like "Oregairu". However, the execution falls short, with storyline becoming convoluted and the character development becoming inconsistent. While the production quality is average, not detracting from the viewing experience, the animation is subpar. The sound design, particularly the use of music, is out of place and sometime jarring. The direction and screenplay could have been more polished. The dialogue often feels forced, and the narrative suffers from pacing issues ... |