Anime 38329 Seishun Buta Yarou Wa Yumemiru Shoujo No Yume Wo Minai Reviews Filter Check 2

"Rascal Does Not Dream of a Dreaming Girl" is the sequel to the 13-episode anime series "Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai" that took the internet and otaku world by storm in the forth quarter of 2018 with its flabbergasting title and premise. Adapted from the light novel series with the same name, at first glance it seemed as if it would be another adaptation of an unreasonably long and clickbait title, however it turned out to actually have a beating heart and an interesting direction to take its viewers to. The chemistry between Azusagawa Sakuta and Sakurajima Mai was reminiscing of ... that of Araragi and Senjougahara from the "Monogatari Series " and the paranormal activities seemed to be inspired from "The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya", however those would not be the only elements the series borrows from its predecessors, but I digress.

The movie-sequel aims to tackle the arc of Makinohara Shouko, an important character in the life of our bickering protagonist as she was his saviour in time of need during his early years, as well as the catalyst for Sakuta's chest scars to reopen. A truly enigmatic figure, as she was restricted to the sidelines in the main adaptation, given little to none importance until the end of the final arc, when she once again comes to the aid of Sakuta. Come this movie, Shoko is the one in need of assistance from our snarky protagonist as he tries unravel the truth behind her puberty syndrome and find an alternative path to the excruciating choice he's forced to make.

The opening shots send us back to when Shoko was in fourth grade and is shown having troubles completing a paper sheet with her plans and dreams for the future. It is established that her difficulty for filling in the sheet would play an important role as the movie progresses. The movie then cuts back to the present day and the problems arise.

Firstly, the pacing is all over the place as the days are skipped by in order for the movie to just arrive from point A to point B, without much reflection to the events that would unfold. This greatly hinders the emotional revelation during its climax as it leaves the viewer with a sense of "well that happened" instead of "this had an impact on me". It is to be mentioned that the pacing is not always poor, in fact, the beginning of the movie fits perfectly as it steadily builds towards the mid section of the movie. Unfortunately, it does not maintain the same steadiness as it advances and by the end of the movie it finishes in a satisfactory, if abrupt manner.

Secondly, the existence of this movie itself does not justify itself as it achieves nothing that cinematography does. The whole arc gives the impression of an overly extended episode of the original anime. The animation, while good, was nothing spectacular as it remained one the same level as the 13-episode anime series. The scene composition did not improve either and the use of realistic background elements, while it was a nice touch, it did not reach the same artistic expression as other films did. As it stands, "Rascal Does Not Dream of a Dreaming Girl" is a quick money grab designed to lure the fanbase into watching it under the guise of offering a cinematic experience, but delivering an OVA worth of excitement. At least that way it would have fixed the pacing issues.

The final problem with this movie is the convoluted story leading into a redundant conclusion. Throughout its runtime it is given extraordinary importance to the choice that Sakuta is forced to make and it is one that severely affects him when makes up his mind. However, this is immediately dismissed as he gets another chance and Shouko does what she could have done from the beginning, as the movie decides that all the drama the characters went through was all for naught. The story advances in an obvious way, but tries to hide it with empty misdirection so that when the twist happens, the viewer is caught off-guard leaving him in a state of fabricated sorrow thanks to the emotional manipulation of the movie. It tries to replicate what "Steins;Gate" or "The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya" did with its main lead, however it results in a watered down copy of the two.

This is not to say the film is just one giant mess. There are some good moments as well. The chemistry between the characters is back better than ever and the dialogues are just as entertaining and diverting. There is also a very heartfelt conversation between Sakuta and Futaba which proved more emotional than the main twist, thanks to how it was shot and the splendid work of the voice actors. Another upside is present on the audio front. The background music was perfectly fit throughout the film, especially at the end with the insertion of the ED song, as well as the magnificent work of the voice actors.

In conclusion, "Rascal Does Not Dream of a Dreaming Girl" is a heavily flawed movie which little to no reason for existing as it borrows elements from two other more critically acclaimed IPs, which ultimately fails to become its own thing. The film is not a must-watch unless you are a big fan of the original series and desperately want to see more content.

Quick note - I mentioned one spoiler in the pacing section and this is also my first review. So please bare with whatever errors, typos, or problems that you may find in my writing.

So this movie is rated unbelievably high on MAL. A lot of people love it and a good amount of people hate it. I've read the reviews and comments from both sides and I've come to a conclusion as to why this movie is so high on the rankings. That conclusion being, people are either going into this with a lot of bias from the tv series, or they are willingly ignoring ... the flaws that are present.

Story - 6/10
I thought the premise itself had a lot of potential. The tv series always hinted at the mystery surrounding Shouko Makinohara and hearing this would be the focus intrigued me. Add some time travel stuff in there and there you go. So how was the execution? Terrible. The time travel aspect was completely glanced over and made very little sense. They explained it over a small number of exchanges and it almost feels as though the writers are saying, "blah blah blah. Don't think too hard about it and just trust what we are saying." Well the problem is, this aspect which is actually a major and I mean major plot point isn't explained in a coherent manner nor is it properly developed which is just completely off putting. In the end, my reaction was just ok… nothing special.

Art - 4/10
There is absolutely no change from the tv series to the movie. You're telling me that one of the most trending anime during its airing couldn't improve the art quality even by a little for a movie release. Is that a joke? Like I get that what makes bunny girl senpai so compelling is the story and characters, but at the very least, for a movie, I would expect some improvement. I simply cannot rate this any higher and I can't see why fans themselves would rate it higher than a 5. The art has always been average maybe even less and the movie does nothing to improve on that.

Characters - 7/10
The characters are the same. The one thing worth noting though is Mai and Sakuta's relationship gets focused on/developed so if you wanna see those two interact with each other (which I personally did) then yea the movie might be worth at least trying.

Sound - 5/10
To be honest, the soundtrack wasn't memorable for me. The voice acting was pretty good.

Pacing - 4/10
The pacing is very very weird for the opening scenes. Things kinda seem out of nowhere and I felt lost as to why certain scenes were the way they were. The pacing gets better over time, but throughout my entire experience, it never felt right. Probably because the pacing is jumpy and inconsistent. As an additional note, this movie lacked emotion. Not in the sense that it didn't have emotional scenes, but rather it failed to evoke emotion out of me. For example when certain characters supposedly died, I felt nothing. Like legitimately nothing. My reaction was mainly oh… that happened. I knew they would come back and the movie was simply being dramatic to make the situation more tense than it actually was. Now, being dramatic isn't a bad thing, but the way it was handled alongside the pacing was just bad. If I may compare, thinking back to the Kaede arc in the tv series. That arc was easily my favorite, and the final moments when Kaede "died" and the old Kaede came back made me tear up. From the way Kaede's manner of speaking changed to the slight shift in Sakuta's voice. In that scene, we the viewers knew what had occurred and we also knew how much it hurt Sakuta. But in the movie, as I've already said, it doesn't reach that same effect. In fact, it's nowhere close to it.

Enjoyment - 5/10
If I haven't made this clear already, this movie is meh. The story had potential, but turned out meh. The art is still meh. The sound is meh. The pacing is bleh. The one thing that's good is the characters and that's mainly because I ship Mai and Sakuta.

Final Thoughts - 5/10
I'm a fan of the original series and seeing this movie was a huge disappointment. Apparently the top reviews loved this movie going as far as to rate 9 or 10, which it clearly is not. But maybe you'll like it idk. From my perspective, this movie was bad, but I rated higher because of my bias to the original. Personally, I wouldn't recommend this unless you really love the tv series. And even then, you might not really enjoy it. My suggestion would be to turn your brain off and maybe you won't get annoyed by the terrible pacing and lack of detail. In the end, MAL rating are driven by its users. And those users are fans of this show. Hence, there is bias and a whole lot apparently as I thought the first and last arcs of the tv series were far greater than what the movie offered. Hopefully the rating changes in the future when fans come to their senses.

Story 6:
The plot feels like it trying to make you cry. If the plot is a person it would be a manipulative person.

Art 6:
It is okay. Meaning that it is barely better then the anime series itself.

Sound 5:
Same as the anime.

Character 6:
... It's ok. Expect what you get from the anime, but even less from the side characters.

Enjoyment 6:
If I had shut off my brain it could been a eight, that or if this was my first sad anime movie. Unfortunately it's not my first sad anime movie.

Overall 6:

Personal opinons
it's a 6/10 or 5.5/10 after comparing to other similar movies for me.
It's genericly done and casual anime fans who don't nitpick at detail like I do will enjoy it more, but if your like me and have watched actual 9/10 solid sad tragic anime movies you probably be turned off by the ending. It's overrated if you ask me, there are much better anime movies of this kind.
The tip to fully enjoy this movie is to turn off your brain.

Sorry if I broke any review guideline rules, this is my first time doing a review

Movie was just meh, i have seen similar story done better elsewhere, or at least heard of. The characters mostly talk about exposition and the story, not to much growth here. And the sad moments felt very forced. I counted the crying scenes and the was 8 in the main, too many. If you don't already really care about these charterers you really wont give a shit about the story. and in my case I didn't much, the first season is one of my faves but this was just boring and underwhelming. also story was super contrived and somewhat meaningless. nothing really ... changes and the characters, as I mentioned before, don't rally grow. Other than the main characters love, which is like the one thing you knew about going in so okay? Also as always my whole thoughts are not recorded here so feel free to message me and discuss.

Whatever, disappointed compared to the show I give 5/10, try harder next time

Potential spoilers.

Short Review:
If you liked the series, you'll like this movie.


Longer Review:
This was a satisfying continuation of the story we saw in the TV series that aired last fall: the truth behind Shoko and Sakuta's relationship is fully revealed.

Like in the TV series, the story arc starts strong but drags towards the end* and also seems suspiciously derivative of other anime {Steins;Gate, Angel Beats, Monogatari, Makoto Shinkai's stuff}. Despite potentially derivative elements, we're given a presentation that's uniquely Bunny Senpai, so I won't harp on this too much.
...
The animation and sound design weren't anything to write home about (they basically match the TV anime quality, with less still cuts). Fortunately, the characters are as like-able as ever for their witty banter and antics. I'm not quite sure there's more depth to them than that likeable facade we're presented with, though.

Despite the shortcomings, I can't say I didn't enjoy the film during its 90 minute run time. The movie ran me through the gamut of emotions I'd expected and more: I laughed, felt my eyes water up, and smiled. I just know I won't think about it too hard in the future -- maybe that's because I'm in the future right now.

6.5/10

* Perhaps the limitations of Hajime Kamoshida's writing are showing again *cough* Sakurasou *cough*

Last Christmas, I gave you my heart, the very next day, I scorned my late girlfriend.

Rascal Does Not Dream of a Dreaming Girl, however, a little spoiler, this rascal does and is kinda dumbfounded by it and does not how effectively handle the situation.

I'm taking that you are reading this review having watched the movie or at least know about the series of the 'Rascal Does Not Dream Of Bunny Girl Senpai', so let me get straight to the matter. I am disappointed. Truly, what I just watched shocks me by how bad and inconsistent the writing. So as you know, our main character revolves ... around a few main and supporting characters. So it is really easy to spot the upcoming plot and what was about to happen. Like, not even trying to joke, if you can recall the scene when Mai-san saved Sakuta by shoving him away and taking the hit. I fucking called it, like, on point, 15 minutes before what happened I call the exact thing that happened. Another issue I faced was that, why did it take Sakuta so damn long to decide, he took so long that he fucked up the situation. Like seriously, it was shown that he accepted that Shouko would die, this was 12 days before it was said that he was gonna be hit by a car. Why is our main character so indecisive about the choice, like come on, I really felt the plot was just meant to be dragged on the longest, long enough that it was a movie. This whole plot seriously could had be done in like, 3 episodes in the series, 4 max. Plus none of this all matters in the end cause both Sakuta and Shouko and Mai all survived, so why does this movie exist. I really feel this movie is pointless in view of the series, if I was new this, yes maybe I would have liked it better, but I'm not and I am aware how great the writing can be. Knowing the series, I am super let down by what the movie has to offer. I just can't stand it why if Sakuta loves Mai so much, he can't make a damn choice before 24th of December. What's worst is that his future ass-self has to go back in time to save himself from his incompetents. Moreover, the show uses cheap emotional tricks to fool the audience, with crying scenes and touching scenes and so on. I seriously hate this cliche trash of a writing. Finally, what the fuck is with that ending, yes fine, Shouko saved her fucking ass, but that doesn't give her and Sakuta the right to remember each other. Like, COME ON, they went through all that shit just because Shouko wanted to feel like a adult? What? Wack bro.

-SCORES-

Character- 6/10: Our main dude, Sakuta, was normal for the first half of the movie, he was the Sakuta we all known and love from the series. On the other hand, the Sakuta from the second half, especially the one in 'present' time one, is so in denial. So much so that he fucking refuses to accept his future-self advise, what trash did I just watched. He is very inconsistent at parts and I really hated that. Another thing, why is Sakuta the centre of every female character, except his sister. Mui is understandable but why Futaba and damn, does Sakuta mean so much to Shouko. I hate this direction, placing so much emphasizes on one character that ever burden lays upon him. This score is mainly targeted at Sakuta, Mui and Shouko, cause they are the only characters that appear consistently throughout the movie.

Art- 8/10: This is expected from the studio, so really nothing much to say except they did it well. Just as good and maybe slightly better than the series.

Writing- 3/10: Shame. Most of the issue are above, this is the downfall of the whole show. I really could have seen the 'surprise' plot a mile away before it even happened so the story does not shock me or move me much like other people. Those reviewers giving this show anything above a 7? Fine, they have the rights to do so, but I have a feeling they fell for the cheap emotional tricks the show offered and gave this show a 7 and above. No, this movie is bad, the writing is far off the series and I and really let down. The plot was so stale that I even came up with interesting plots for my satisfactory. Like, if future Sakuta couldn't stop his present self or Mui, why don't he try stop the car instead? Yes is dumb but it is more interesting than the shit show I've seen. But who am I to say, you be the judge.

Sound- 7/10: Hard to get the OST from all the raging of the bad writing, I say it did it's job. Especially at those emotional scenes, you sneaking bastard. It definitely effected tons of viewers thus giving this show a 8.75, but yeah... It's fine I guess.

Overall, disappointed, sadden and just hope that the next season would be better.

Light 5

I don't normally go for movies due to their length and my limited time. But I was pleasantly surprised to see that there was a sequel to the Seibuta anime and that it seemed to have done well by MAL rating standards. I decided to check it out.

It's been a while since the Seibuta anime aired, and my memory is foggy, but this movie really fell short of the anime and my expectations for it.

Let's start with the easier parts to review. The art is basically the same as the anime's. I read one other review after watching the movie, and I do agree that ... a movie should have a bigger budget and therefore at least better art, but to me this is not a dealbreaker for a series that had decent art to start with. The soundtrack part could have been better for sure. The Seibuta anime OP was catchy and brilliant. I don't remember the anime ED too much but there was nothing in the movie soundtrack that caught my ear.

Now, the story and characters. I personally saw the Seibuta anime as falling inbetween the Monogatari Series and Oregairu, the former being firmly supernatural and the latter being firmly realistic. What these series have in common is how they 1) lead viewers to consider thought-provoking concepts and multiple viewpoints; and 2) utilise dialogue and interactions to bring their characters to life through highlighting their motivations and emotions. Seibuta took a leaf from each through utilising a 'realistic setting' combined with a supernatural plot device to drive its story.

However, the movie threatened this impression. Now, I really would rather not spoil, but since I'm recommending that you don't watch this, I have to divulge some generics without going into details.

Our protagonist, Sakuta, has a dilemma. He is forced to choose between Mai, his girlfriend, and his first crush, Shoko, who interestingly shows up in both an adult version that is a rival to Mai, and a middle-school version, who turns out to have a fatal illness. Using the "Puberty Syndrome" as the plot device which we saw throughout the anime, we find out how there exist two Shokos, what is the relationship between them, and how Sakuta is forced into his dilemma. This summary covers up to the middle of the movie - which was ok, but by then, the tension is built-up and the audience is made to wonder - what will Sakuta do?

There's nothing wrong with a dilemma - what viewers care about is how it is resolved - it's usually more about the process over the outcome. Sakuta's dilemma is then followed by a catastrophe. Again, process over outcome. But the movie butchered them both. There is a sudden disappearance of logic which is replaced by melodrama and a soap opera plot. The earlier part of the movie had some similar aspects, but I thought it was a one-off and paid it no heed. Nope. It wasn't. The melodrama/soap opera grew from there and proved that it was going to stay. It became clear that the intent was less to present a good story but rather to pull at the viewers' heartstrings and force empathy that would lead one to feel that 'because it made me feel, it was good.' I fell for it too - there were points when I went "oh wow that's so sad." And then I went "oh wow that's so sad" for an entirely different reason when I saw exactly where the plot was going.

It went for an asspull (a plot-device-turned-asspull, to be precise) - the vulgar, disguised form of "Deus ex Machina." And since it's an asspull, there's no logic that explains how it works either.

From there, it became entirely predictable. The plot, characters, their emotions, etc. I did not expect so many tears from this movie, but the primary characters become wishy-washy and super-teary. One of the major problems with an asspull however, is that because it allows for a reset, everything that happened up to that point and after - the plot, character development, emotions, etc - becomes unconvincing at best, and void at worst.

While we're on primary characters, as the movie progressed, it was clear that the side characters - an important part of the Seibuta anime - were being phased out to make way for a love-triangle between the primary characters. By the end, while each side character gets their appearance, and some of them do play a role in the plot, I did not feel like they had really developed in any meaningful way. But then again, I didn't feel that way for the primary characters either.

What happened? The Seibuta anime had proved to me that it was much more than all these things. Its characters were decently fleshed, there were thought-provoking-but-believable plot points, and it was enjoyable. Despite being a sequel to the anime, the movie did not follow the anime's successful formula.

Now, I note that this movie adapted 2 volumes from the LN (which i have not read). The question then is did all this melodrama, unhinged emotions and poorly-developed plot points come from the LN too? Considering the anime's source material, I find it hard to believe. One would need to read the LN volumes, but my guess is that the intent was to force a feels reaction from the audience - an emotional hook, if you will.

In conclusion, the movie was a disappointment in how it sought to pander to the emotions to cover up for its inadequacies (and even then it failed in its deception). I watch shows for the plot and characters, and while some series/movies don't really promise you too much, 'thought-provoking' series like Seibuta, Monogatari and Oregairu invite viewers to judge them on these aspects. Well, Seibuta's movie failed. If you are a Seibuta fan, you, like Sakuta, may be faced with a dilemma - watch so you know what happens after the Seibuta anime ended so you won't FOMO should a new anime season come out - or sacrifice 90 minutes of your time on something which may affect your impressions of this series. Let's hope you make a better, more reasonable choice than Sakuta (and I) did, and remember, you have no asspull to save you after you make your choice.

A bit slow in the start and personally I don't really like Shoko. I feel her character is a bit boring and disconnected. The movie throws some the better characters to the side in this Movie that where in the Anime to a larger degree.

Took some time to get into the movie, that was one tear jerker moment but it felt a bit too unreal to be anymore than that.

The ending is pretty unfulfilling considering how in-depth the rest of the movie is although it doesn't leave any unanswered questions

In honesty a disappointing follow up to the anime.

Story: 6/10
Art 8/10
... Sound: 6/10
Character: 5/10
Enjoyment: 6/10
Overall: 6/10

Rascal Does Not Dream of a Dreaming Girl is a terrible “end” to a nearly perfect series. The ending was one of the worst pieces of work ever tacked on to a series and seems more like a cash grab than an actual movie. From emotionless scenes, unnecessary character introductions, and senseless plot holes the movie just comes off as dumb, stupid, and pointless.
One of the most noteworthy flaws of this movie is the deaths. The deaths are meaningless and empty. Throughout the movie three characters die in total: Azusagawa, Sakurajima, and Makinohara. The most tragic of these deaths is Sakurajima’s death as she sacrificed ... herself to save Azusagawa after her mental breakdown in the subway station. Her death feels sincere and permanent but this only marks the beginning of the end for this movie.
This movie begins to fall apart as the audience is forced to suffer through a boring, stereotypical “depressed boyfriend” narrative as Azusagawa must live without Sakurajima. The narrative is overdone in general and this movie does no favors for it. The movie takes even more of a fall after Azusagawa takes a potion from Futaba that lets him go into the past where he can choose to let himself and Sakurajima live, but this would result in Makinohara’s death. This seems to be very important as the choices he makes her will impact the show for the rest of the series.
The remainder of the movie is spent by Azusagawa trying to correct what happened last time. Similar to Sakurajima at the start of the show, no one can see Azusagawa, except for some reason all of his friends which makes no sense and is never explained. He is able to find Sakurajima at one of her commercial shoots and he tells her he will fix everything and not to jump in front of the car to save him. Instead of letting himself die, Azusagawa humps in front of the car allowing future him to die but present him to live on. As a result Makinohara dies. This seems like a perfect place to end the movie but instead Azusagawa is able to find a timeline where Makinohara finishes a “What do you want to do when you group up” that she didn’t do in fourth grade which resulted in her developing puberty system which killed her. In this new timeline she never gets heart problems due to finishing the assignment and all three of them live life as normal. Even though this is bad, it gets even worse. Instead of allowing Makinohara to live on and everyone to have forgotten her, Azusagawa sees her at the beach and is able to regain all of his memories of her making the movie ultimately useless and a waste of time.
The only saving grace of this movie is the fact that it is of the Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai series and as a result has the amazing characters, backstory, music, and more previously introduced in the anime. This movie is definitely worth a watch for fans of the anime, but is not worth a rewatch and struggles to stand out as a memorable movie.

I feel oddly ambivalent towards Seishun Buta Yarou wa Yumemiru Shoujo no Yume wo Minai, which I'm going to abbreviate as the Pig and Bunny Movie. On the one hand, if you really liked the TV series then this makes a lot of sense as an OVA / movie add-on. It gives you a chance to have a last gathering with Mai, Sakuta and their friends to say farewell. Regarding production values, I would say the Pig and Bunny movie looks and sounds great. You can listen to the fabulous voice acting cast croon that marvelous song as the ending credits ... roll. So what's not to like?

Well, I'm hard pressed to say the story is any good. I didn't enjoy the pseudo-science in the TV series and I thought it was even more disjointed and cringe-worthy in this movie. The plot seems designed to blatantly fish for an emotional reaction from the viewer. For example, I find Mai and Sakuta to be charming and I really enjoy their conversations. Pig and Bunny tries to leverage this good will and use it to beat you over the head with a melodramatic story arc. Rather than feel moved, I was annoyed. Was it a dream? An exploration of the theory of relativity? I understand modern physics pretty well and maybe that prevented me from enjoying Pig and Bunny more.

So I came out of the movie feeling odd. They got the feel of the various scenes spot-on. Meeting your first love on the beach, a last rendezvous on Christmas Eve, difficult decisions and feeling regret, it's all there. I loved the TV series because I enjoyed the FEEL of the various scenes, complete with the the people who resided therein. However, it's almost as if the writer had these (wonderful) visions in their head and did not know how to stitch it together into a gripping yarn. Instead, we get kind of a strange mish-mash that doesn't flow well and frankly felt like bits and pieces borrowed from better stories.

Should you watch it? if you really, really enjoyed the TV series and you want to have a final farewell party with them, go ahead. For everyone else, it's safe to skip this because it's essentially more of the same, including the same irritating parts.

Is it bad that I barely enjoyed this at all? I didn't hate it, but for it being the 7th top anime movie... I guess I just didn't understand why? I didn't think it was bad, but something about the plot seemed very forced, and unnatural. I feel like I would enjoy the series better.

Also, there were multiple times throughout the movie I had to go back and rewatch scenes, sometimes more than once. I feel like some of the "quantum physics" was partly the writers of the show trying to make things waaay more complicated than they needed to be.

*SPOILERS BELOWWWWWWWW DONTTTTT READ*

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Like time ... travel is time travel. It isn't any new concept. I feel like they could have just kept it simple without confusing the audience. I think the relationships could have been built out more... particularly all the women in Sakuta's life. There were so many it felt like borderline harem in a way. Which isn't bad, but I wish I could have seen a more meaningful bond between him and all of the people in his life. The characters ALL seemed pretty one dimensional.

I think I'm going to give the series a try though! I feel like maybe if that one is more detailed I would enjoy it more!!

There are very few shows that managed to make me write them a comprehensive review. Part of this process is understanding the creative process one might undertake when making a work of art, and as such, it might also serve to put my words on paper to understand them better myself. What I am trying to say is that the show itself, while not bad, it reflects ideals, themes, and progression that wasn't even necessary, while digging its plot holes deeper than ever before, and I am having a hard time understanding why this was done in the first place.

If you liked the anime and ... usually go along with the plot points presented without questioning them much, you can safely watch the anime and will be just fine. If you, however, question the nature of these superpowers and think more deeply about story points and elements that encompass these powers, it would be best not to watch it. If you are in doubt, you can read along as I discuss the many aspects of this anime through the following sections:

Visual Presentation 9, Voice Acting 8, Story 5, Story Progression 7, Character Development 5, and Themes 3.



Visual Presentation:

The shot composition is fine. There are little details in the behavior of people that are shown, the camera is where we need it when we need it. There are no unnecessary shots. While this might be a plus, there is also a lack of creativity involved. The fact that we are thrown into the story as a whole without propper introductions like it's another episode of the anime was an interesting idea as well, but again, played very safe.

The artwork itself is also not what I would call "movie quality", but again, gets the job done without any noticeable flaws. The characters and everything that is rendered in within the lens of the movie stayed the same as with the TV anime. No jump in quality what so ever.

As such, with all the above mentioned, this section will receive a 9/10.



Voice Acting:

The voice acting was great with the exception of some scenes that felt a bit... off? Mai's crying scenes were the main reason this is so, most of which felt unnatural to say the least. The delivery on most lines was great, but some emotional impact was lost in others when it shouldn't be.

I will not go over everything, but I will give this section a 8/10. It's not the best, but it's still very good.



Story/Writing:

Oh boy, here we go. There will be SPOILERS in this section as well as the rest of the review. If you only need the scores as we go on, I listed them all above.

There are a few things in regards to the story that fell flat, the first of which is the small detour in the main plot to save Mai. I thought about it, and it only serves as a device, later on, to say that they will still keep their memories from this fake future(which by itself is a lot of BS). There is no other reason behind it and it brings other questions about too.

The future changed and it originally was Sakuta's heart that was given to Shouko, but later on became Mai's because of the time shenanigans. Do you understand how rare it is for two different people to be able to donate a heart that would work in this situation? You would need to be the same blood type as the other person in the first place unless you are an O. I checked the wiki and there are no mentions of blood types here so I don't know for sure, but let's just assume that it just happened that they both could be donors. Yet, if that is the case, how did we jump from one timeline to the next? There should have been a lot more memories being altered than his scars missing. Glancing over these details is just bad. They just throw a line that the future changed, but that's not reflected in the change at all.

There is also the part about going back to the past. It's contrived as all hell. Just rejecting your own future with strong emotion is enough to send anyone in the past? Can anyone get this Puberty Syndrome if that is the case? It's just a contrived time turner. There are so many inconsistencies with this. There is also the thing with himself being damaged, with the scars, after interacting with just a part of his former body. If he were to be in the proximity of himself, just disappearing wouldn't cut it. It should have been more agonizing, rather than just merging together. The author stated a rule for how the universe works, then re-written that rule to suit his needs. If they touch they should merge, then either the scars are BS because they shouldn't happen because his heart wasn't touching the other one, or the scars are the usual way, and he should have died painfully if he touched himself. If just close proximity rends your flesh, imagine direct contact.

There is also the fact that Shouko knows this way of going back to the past. How? If she is really from the future and uses this way of traveling back to the past, then what Futaba told us about time relativity doesn't really make sense. At all. It's just this time travel method.

There is the part where Makinohara knows everything about this while being two people, which would be impossible to say the least. Maybe they merged at some point, but isn't stated.

And other similar things. I did the indulgent thing and gave this section a 5/10.



Story Progression:

How the story evolves, basically. Since the story itself is pretty all over the place, and because of this the progression is also all over the place. It doesn't have a line, a curve or anything for that matter. It feels like it just ascends for the first half, then jumps up and down in the middle with the time travel things, then plummets as nothing is done at the end of the movie. No action is undertaken by Sakuta or Mai at the end. Everything just... resolves itself. Like a heart disease cures with hard work and determination.

7/10



Character Development:

Hey kids, character development is nice and all, but are you interested in character regression?

Sakuta is a pile of bricks that can't save anyone because of his pride. Mai is on the right track, but because of her pride doesn't do anything but die by herself. That's basically it. For the sake of the plot these characters can't even decide if they want to live or not, and when they do decide they want to live, they change their mind at the last second.

This display is shown first hand over the phone call between Sakuta and Sakuta. One of them is just a bundle of pride that wants to die with glee at the thought of saving someone else, the other one tells them they are a moron for thinking of that because they saw what that pride can do and what he has to lose. But the thing is that the one that wants to live does so because of the drastic measures shown, not because of anything else. They don't value their life, but the lives of others. He only does this to save Mai, not himself. Which isn't how things went throughout the story so far. He made his decisions with others in mind, but also conscious of the things he is to lose if he went too far. Dying is too far. No normal person would choose that over the lover that begs and pleads with them to live.

Sakuta basically regressed to an asshole. The growth he is shown here is artificial and it would have been more impactful for his character to just make the decision to save himself outright.

Mai also regressed a lot. She was well-intentioned enough in the TV anime, making decisions that would be in her detriment, however, she always went beyond in what she did to keep her relationship with Sakuta. Just accepting his death after he showed his own desire to keep the status quo should have been met with something more if she was intent on keeping him alive while getting herself killed. She said she was scared that he would come to hate her, but getting herself killed was better? Somehow?

Shouko also know what happened, but didn't, but did, and she manipulated people to try and do her bidding. You would think a grown woman in a child's body could do things better, but whatever.

5/10



Themes:

After watching this movie to the end, I wondered... What was the point of everything? Why did they invalidate a whole anime season for nothing? What was there to gain from it?

There was no greater theme, no theme of adolescence in this movie, no theme of actual loss, and no theme of hardship because it was all negated at the very end.

If she could do this from the start why was all this necessary? Why was bringing this much hardship on these people ok? What was the purpose of the movie itself? To show us that this didn't happen at all? The title in itself is a throwback to this moment because the Scoundrel doesn't dream of anything, it was all a farce.

From the end scene, you would think that everything went according to the events of the first timeline, but we have no confirmation of that other than small details. There is also the memories part of it all. They say that they will try to do something, but Makinohara is the only one that does things. Nothing changes, yet everything changed. Only for this sacrifice to be denied at the end, because it didn't matter that this was a different timeline.

Why didn't I talk about this in the Story section? Because the themes around this show should have been meaningful. In the TV anime, how things progressed and how things ended up had their themes of adolescence and the hardships that come with that. But with this ending? Nothing matters.

While watching this movie, nothing matters from the start. There is no meaning to be taken from anything.

Why did the whole going back in time to save Mai happen? From a thematic perspective. Idk, ask the author. There is nothing to be gained from that. Nothing to be explored from contrived devices and everything. They put that in because they wanted to show that memories can be transferred, but that didn't do anything in the long run.

Everything in this movie has no greater meaning other than, "that might be cool if it happened".

3/10 because the ED tying up with the movie reference worked.



In conclusion:

There are a lot more things I did not cover because I would have to go on forever, and I have neither the time or patience to do it. It was a disappointing experience, this movie. As someone that likes to solve a mystery at the same time as the detective, it was meaningless. Perhaps pieces of entertainment such as this aren't really suited for this sort of approach, but since the author seemed like they tried their best to make this narrative work with these mechanics in mind, only through logic can it be shown how wrong it was.

Overall score: 6.2



I am going to address the fact that this is the single review, and single anime currently present on this MAL account. I am going to use this one for reviews, and only for shows that need to be analyzed in depth. I feel that if I don't say this outright, my opinion might not be taken seriously by people scrolling by.

idk if this is considered as a spoiler but if they just made it so that the whole theme of the movie was that you can't save everyone you care about because some people are just meant to die then that would've been fine by me. it's meant to be a tear-jerker and yea maybe some parts aroused my tear ducts but nothing in there was strong enough to make me cry, the story is somewhat contrived and melodramatic, I enjoyed the anime series so this was a nice addition I guess? But as some of the reviews, the execution wasn't super well done. Fukashigi ... no Carte is still a bop tho.

I honestly don't know how to feel about this movie. One thing I know for sure is that this movie isn't 100% original in terms of storytelling, and that this movie reminded me of "Your Name" ( a lot, and I'll explain why). SPOILERS WARNING!!!!!
-
-
The reasons why I said that this movie reminded me of "Your Name" is because there are a lot of clues.
1) Mai-san, who died halfway in the movie ( Mitsuha, who died due to the meteor strike)
-
2) Main character went back in time in order to save Mai-san ( or the whole village including Mitsuha in "Your Name")
-
3) If the ... main character wanted to save the person he loves, his memory got wiped off of someone/something
(Sakuta got his memories of Shouko wiped off in order to save Mai-san)
(Taki got his memories of Mitsuha and her village wiped off in order to save both of them)
-
4) After the main character finally accomplished, the main character remembered something at the end of the movie
( Sakuta finally remembered Shouko at the beach / Both Taki and Mitsuha finally recognised (NOT FULLY) each other even both of their memories got wiped off )
-
That's mostly it, I'm not trying to say that this movie is bad or anything, I actually like the characters, Sakuta and Mai-san. This movie doesn't COMPLETELY ripping off of "Your Name", it does have a little bit for originality (No body switching for this movie). What I'm trying to say is that you can still enjoy the movie without watching "Your Name", but since I really like "Your Name" and that it's very popular, I just wish that this movie need to try something new even though it was inspired by "Your Name".

Seishun Buta Yarou wa Yumemiru Shoujo no Yume wo Minai


The movie follows the events from the first season and is directly linked to the last episodes of the anime adaptation.

The film takes over the atmosphere from the previous season and all character traits. Whoever liked the series will definitely like the film as well. Because this also closes the plot in the end.

Well, the movie not only takes over the noteworthy things from the series but also the negative. And here the "plot" is definitely in the foreground.

Apart from the fact that the characters perceived the whole "puberty reality warper syndrome" as an everyday experience, ... like eating and going to the toilet, until the bitter end.

And here, too, the explanations of what happened have once again reached great heights. In that sense, the explanation for the time travel in this film is actually even more impressive than the one with the toaster. I will certainly remember.
Now and then I get the feeling that this anime is an actual parody of the science fiction genre, which unfortunately is not the case.

Everything was built on an abstract theme without any real explanations, and then the main story took off. After a few escalations and several question marks, the climax came and also the end. The ending, as expected, was a complete disappointment, but it could have ended worse.

Despite all the mistakes and the nonsensical logic, I found the film quite worth seeing, even if it hardly contains any qualities that speak for it in terms of content.

In the end, the characters were just a bunch of pseudo-intellectual adolescents who could only build slightly cynical sympathy. They are certainly still among the better characters, but their potential has not been used to the full. The main female protagonist became secondary.

The author undoubtedly had no idea of ​​the subject he had dared to tackle.

Ughhh- the only word to describe this movie.
First of all, even after re-watching I didn't get how many things happened. In the prequel you could understand things but I doubt many people got this and when you just don't get the plot the show will never feel good to you. If we are talking about Animation and sound, it is more gross. In the prequel, there were such vibrant colors; perfect for its content and while background sound was really not anything, I myself particularly enjoyed the OP. But unfortunately Cloverworks sucked in case of Animation in this movie; no vibrant colors, backgrounds hastily done ... that results in objects being not much detailed. And surprisingly, there's NO new music. NO new music, like no. In the ending they just added the same ending song of the series. These two factors affected the show greatly but that is not all.
Jokes, Sakuta's pervy jokes along with others, they were a great source of entertainment for me and as a bonus we don't get to see any cute scenes at all, no Kaede clinging to his brother, no nothing. Well, this show was made of content that wouldn't match with funny environment but I thought that maybe the director or whoever has that sort of thing/writer of the light novel would be witty enough to add some jokes as to make it more of a good meal for us fans to digest but no luck. Though one thing I am happy about is that there were no new characters cause if new characters just kept popping up and Sakuta kept on solving their problems, this show would be in the ditch.
Anyway, a lot of revelations and well, kinda emotional things going on; all together it's enough to be not called a bad show but even as a fan, I wouldn't call it good.