Contains some mild spoilers.
"Demon Slayer is carried by its animation"
A common take that haters of this show love to spew, but how true is it actually?
Demon Slayer S2 picks up immediately where the movie leaves off with the main trio and now the sound hashira going to the "entertainment district" to kill a demon residing there. It introduces us to the new Sound Hashira, and also new villains, in the form of a pair of brother-sister demons.
It goes without saying that Demon Slayer's fight scenes look spectacular, i dont think i need to spend much time praising the visuals or its ... choreography. When people talk about or hype up Demon Slayer, this is the first thing that comes to mind. While Demon Slayer may not be Ufotable's best work (that goes to Heaven's Feel in my opinion), it does not change the fact that it is still undeniably one of the most well-animated shows in the medium.
The score is by the renowned Yuki Kajiura, and its decent. It compliments the animation and the fights well. It hits when it matters, nothing much else to say about it. The Aimer OP and ED, while they are very nice songs to listen to, do not really fit the dark, gritty tone that the show was trying to adopt, especially towards the latter half of the season, but i dont think this means a lot in the grand scheme of things so i wont dwell too long on it.
Now onto the less amazing parts of Demon Slayer.
Demon Slayer's character writing is very polarising. Tanjiro, probably the most interesting character, is an altruistic, selfless empath. He never fails to see the good in even the worst of demons. He is a nice guy at heart, and easy to get behind which makes for a likeable protagonist, but not necessarily the most interesting to watch. Zenitsu and Inosuke on the other hand, represent running gags that the show has. Inosuke is aggressive, hot-headed and short-tempered, while Zenitsu is a simp. Most of their dialogue and personality revolve around this one trait that they have. While fans may find them to be funny and great comic relief, I am certainly not one of them. The 2 new antagonists have a somewhat endearing sibling relationship, but we are spoon-fed their backstory just as they are about to die. It comes off as if they are forcing us to feel sad for characters that we would otherwise not care about. Because, before the backstory, i saw the 2 villains as one-note, blank slate villains which will surely die by the end of the season. Their backstories are admittedly somewhat sad and heartbreaking and I am sure that these moments do make many viewers feel for the characters, and thats great. However for me, and lots of people i've interacted with, these moments come off as emotionally manipulative and forced.
The dialogue in Demon Slayer is very VERY bloated. There is an extraordinary overuse of monologues. Monologues arent inherently bad, but when its used so much, it gets to the point of being completely meaningless. This causes the flashy, pretty looking fights to become somewhat boring and stale. What do i mean by this? Demon Slayer has a tendency of treating its audience like they are 3 year olds who dont have basic reading comprehension. It feels this need to explain everything that happens on-screen, even the most blatantly obvious things. "I'll slash as hard as i can!", "The slash didnt go through!!" This kind of "walkthrough dialogue" (a term coined by a friend of mine) that almost narrates the events shown, give the fight sequences themselves a lot less impact and make them far less meaningful or immersive.
As for the tonal inconsistencies, there are many sudden tone changes that happens out of the blue. The show would randomly crack a joke in the middle of a fight, the music stops, and some sound effects intended for comic relief start to play. Dont get me wrong, comic relief isnt bad, but the timing is what matters, and Demon Slayer times these comic relief moments IN THE MIDDLE OF AN INTENSE FIGHT SCENE. This breaks immersion, and reduces investment, especially when it comes out of nowhere. Thankfully, as the season progressed, this became less and less of a problem as the show managed to stick to the dark, gritty tone that it had originally intended to adopt.
Demon Slayer is also rampant with plot conveniences. Characters would have broken fingers, be punched in the gut 10 times or so, and still effectively be at full fighting capacity. At one point, Tanjiro goes down, has a flashback about Nezuko, manages to get back up (albeit with a little bit of difficulty and limping), and is suddenly ready to fight again, "Determination conquers all", a common theme throughout the series. So whats the problem here? The injuries and hits that they take feel very meaningless. Yes sure, when they do get hit, they get hit very hard, but why does it matter? They just get back up a minute later as if nothing happened to them. Fingers broken? Just hold the sword with your remaining fingers lmao. Got stabbed through the chest? Just shift the position of your organs lmao. This can potentially stop me from taking the fights seriously, as the stakes become nonexistent. The only real stakes that are present, come at the end of the season, but by then, the fight is over, and the impact that it leaves, is not very significant.
Its easy to see the appeal of Demon Slayer, and i do enjoy what it has to offer. It is easily accessible, easily digestable, and it looks great, making for a very entertaining show to watch, but its definitely not without its fair share of flaws. I imagine the diehard fans of the series either dont consider my issues as flaws, or are willing to overlook the flaws despite them being present. On the other hand, i imagine that the diehard haters think the positives count for little when the myriad of other flaws are present. Both positions are totally reasonable and understandable. Thank you for reading.
Alternative Titles Japanese: 鬼滅の刃 遊郭編 Information Type: TV Episodes: 11 Status: Finished Airing Aired: Dec 5, 2021 to Feb 13, 2022 Premiered: Winter 2022 Broadcast: Sundays at 23:15 (JST) Studios: ufotable Source: Manga Theme: Historical Demographic: Shounen Duration: 26 min. per ep. Rating: R - 17+ (violence & profanity) Statistics Score: 8.751 (scored by 909,945 users) 1 indicates a . Ranked: #442 2 based on the top anime page. Please note that 'Not yet aired' and 'R18+' titles are excluded. Popularity: #86 Members: 1,432,912 Favorites: 24,409 Available AtResources | ReviewsFeb 13, 2022 Contains some mild spoilers. "Demon Slayer is carried by its animation" A common take that haters of this show love to spew, but how true is it actually? Demon Slayer S2 picks up immediately where the movie leaves off with the main trio and now the sound hashira going to the "entertainment district" to kill a demon residing there. It introduces us to the new Sound Hashira, and also new villains, in the form of a pair of brother-sister demons. It goes without saying that Demon Slayer's fight scenes look spectacular, i dont think i need to spend much time praising the visuals or its ... Dec 20, 2021 This show is too much hilarious, the jokes, sense of humor and dialogues are so out of this world that I had to share it with all my friends and family and they all kept laughing as well. Other than that, great animation. Animation: 10/10. For the most part, the show is popular because of it's animation. Of course, UFOTABLE carrying the whole show else I can guarantee that half the people watching it will back down and I really mean it since I have seen way too many people watching it just for the animation. This show really proves that for some people, as long as ... Dec 22, 2021 Kimetsu no Yaiba is bound to be one of the most discussed shows of the season, perhaps the year, crossing to the year 2022 as well. Of glowing prominence within the anime community, this one’s possibly one of the strongest, aside from Mushoku Tensei Season 1 Cour 2, which had finished airing by the time this review of mine was released onto the platform. I find Kimetsu No Yaiba to be a strange phenomenon, bizarre yet one that is worth scrutinising, my position with Kimetsu no Yaiba is also a difficult one it seemed, in accordance to my preference of viewing and observing anime and ... Dec 27, 2021 Kimetsu no Yaiba was, at best, mediocre from the start. While the animation and art direction are incredible, it's far from being the masterpiece that everyone claims it to be. Most of the characters aren't that interesting, and despite that some of them have a deep background, it doesn't really matter since they end up dying anyway right after they fleshed out, preventing us from appreciating a good character like Kyojuro Rengoku and making us feel like he was a wasted potential. Nezuko only exists in the show to give the protagonist a reason to stay alive and as a potential love interest for Zenitsu, we ... Feb 13, 2022 I tried to be patient during the first season and the movie. Now Demon Slayer plagues me again with another season of little progression glossed over with pretty animation. Season 2 for the most part was a recycled and worse version of season 1 because it still has the same problems but made even worse. Season 2 never came close to topping the greatness of episode 19 in season 1, and the last episode was terribly disappointing. The most impressive animation scenes are the only hollow like enjoyment I could get out of this. I can't give it praise. At most it's a guilty pleasure. ... Jun 1, 2022 𝘋𝘦MID 𝘚𝘭𝘢𝘺𝘦𝘳 Ha. But in all seriousness, this new season truly lives up to that title in much too many ways for such an acclaimed series. If you have criticisms, though, you're labeled as a mere elitist. "𝘋𝘦𝘮𝘰𝘯 𝘚𝘭𝘢𝘺𝘦𝘳 is about the simplicity, not everything needs to..." or "it's just a shounen, what did you expect?" Well, what I expected was a coherent experience, which is what I recall the previous installments of 𝘋𝘦𝘮𝘰𝘯 𝘚𝘭𝘢𝘺𝘦𝘳 to have provided at the least. When season 1 came out, it was easy to ignore what many called poor writing and characters, but as time goes on, the excitement of ... Feb 7, 2022 Omg my favorite mc so flawless and perfectly crafted honestly I'm tearing rn because of how much I relate to this masterpiece of a show. I really wish I got to see more of Tanjiro's backstory as seeing it 10 times each episode was not really enough to fully value the depth of his character. The fights were perfectly crafted, making sure I forgot what was happening with a flashback every millisecond and Uzui was so relatable to me with his 3 wives and shi. A big question I had towards the author was as to how Tanjiro was not killed due to zoning out into ... Dec 26, 2021 "Includes Minor Spoilers" Also'-Ignore my horrible grammar'- Well, after the very well recieved movie and that broke Box office records Demon Slayer is back with a season 2. But This review isnt really a review about this season but rather about Demon Slayer as a franchise itself. I have gotta be honest, I like demon slayer but some times I am thinking about it and Then thinking that this is kind of an mess. But not a bad one. In This review I will explain why I think from a certain perspective that this show isnt good. Before you go send hate comments its still my ... Jan 18, 2022 Man where do I begin...there is so much wrong and the only reason I gave it a 6 is because I haven't seen the all of season 2. Season one was genuinely one of the best modern ip's in anime in a long time. It was a beathe of fresh air. It had genuine weight to it, something that makes a generic show into a masterpiece. This weight, grounded in reality, was carried through to the mugen train arc, but is entirely missing here. 7 Episodes in, and this show is lacking a ton of character which made season one amazing. Its missing that weight. Remember in season ... Feb 16, 2022 Since not much has changed since the first season in terms of characters and plot structure, I will instead give you a list of 10 things that made Demon Slayer the success it is. This is done after some chats I had with people who insisted Demon Slayer did not become such a success just because of the animation. Up to a point they were right, since if animation alone was enough then every well animated anime would be a success, something which is not true. So, here are those 10 reasons that made a show with such a by the numbers plot and cast ... Feb 20, 2022 Kimetsu no Yaiba: Yuukaku-hen I like Demon Slayer, I really do. And mostly thanks to what Ufotable has done with this manga. The animations, the dynamics and atmosphere. All of this makes the anime an art form that you practically just soak up. And at the same time, this is a very critical contrast for my taste. On the one hand, I adore this anime and could watch this season a second time right now. Yet, simultaneously, these flaws and problems are hurting me more and more. It is at once one of my favorite shounen and one of the worst shounen I have seen. Demon Slayer ... Feb 15, 2022 Demon Slayer is not all about animation, or is it? All throughout it’s runtime, which started in 2019, Demon Slayer has cemented itself as a contender for not only the most popular shonen of the “new age” but anime in general. With it’s vast character cast and the raw amount of different personalities derived from the aforementioned cast, it manages to appeal to a broad audience, except for one kind of person. That kind of person would be the one that wants to enjoy an anime without being interrupted by an annoying comedy scene every 5 minutes. With the considerable amount of criticism the show has ... Feb 14, 2022 Meh. I don't hate this anime, I just think its average and that's all. The animation is really pretty to look at, the CGI is really good and also it has a nice opening and ending song. The story is also pretty cool, our 3 main characters go to a red light district with a Hashira to kill the big bad demon because the demon on a killing spree. Summarized the plot and shit now time to get to what I like and dislike. Likes- Nice animation, it looks really pretty which is obvious. The fights are really pretty to look at and you can make out everything ... Jan 17, 2022 First review I'm writing, so I hope I get my opinion over. The review also counts in the previous seasons. Story: 4/10 Generic shounen plot, humour very out of place and just horrible overall. I don't think I have laughed at least once, especially with the two characters I'll talk about later. I think the power scaling is fine, but it could be better. Sun breathing is the only somewhat interesting thing that keeps me interested in continuing to watch. I'm also guessing a hashira dies every season from now on, looking back to what happened in the mugen train arc (if this does really happen, it's ... Aug 6, 2022 Snooze fest. Sadly, my feelings regarding the movie have continued into this second season. First, as they did with the movie, they introduce a new round of characters alongside the main three, and the story revolves around them and their conflict. The problem with that is that I don't care. I don't know anything about these new characters, I haven't been with them for long, so when things are happening to them, it doesn't hold any significance to me whatsoever. I understand by helping these new characters, the main three and Nezuko are provided opportunities for growth, but again - it's not enough to keep ... Feb 13, 2022 What can be said about Demon Slayer that wasn't already stated before? We all know that it's one of the most popular anime series since 2019, also that has one of (if not) the best animations ever made. It's worth the praise? Deserve all the sucess or it's overhyped? I'll try to express what I think of Kimetsu no Yaiba without being too harsh. Demon Slayer has a pretty simple story. Kamado Kenjiro discouvers that his entire family has being murdered on cold blood by some mysterious creature, that later on is revealed to be a demon, and one of his sisters was alive - Nezuko and now she ... Jun 8, 2022 *SPOILERS* When Demon Slayer was first released the anime was highly praised and I enjoyed it very much. The Animation was top tier, there was a great soundtrack and the overall concept of it was very unique and attention grabbing. It became a very popular anime, and around that time I was an early anime fan and this became one of my favorites which got me into anime. So the bar was set very high for when the second season was going to release. But it didn't live up to the hype and it was just disappointing. The movie prior to this season was very good ... Mar 4, 2022 Ah yes, the anime is so popular and it has a high rating so it must be good, right? Or so I thought... Well, I'll break down the obvious things... The anime has a great animation or one of the top in the “shounen” type of animes. One of the best fight scene and everything visually. “So if what you said is the anime that great why rate it as a 5? Simple, even though everything visually the anime is a literal masterpiece there's nothing that is special in the plot, characters and such. Demon Slayer also has that big problem like almist every shounen has which is ... Feb 13, 2022 Story This season continues where the last one leaves off. There is nothing groundbreaking or revolutionary though. You get a simple easy to follow story with some pacing problems. The main cast can spend several episodes fighting the villans with little else happening. The monologues during the fights really ruin the pace of the fight. It is amazing that so little can happen within the span of several episodes and this is an aspect of the story that made me lose interest. The humor is also very cringe, rarely funny and often obnoxious. Art The fights are beautifully animated. Art style is very strong as well. ... Jan 10, 2022 TL;DR: This show has a ratio of 5 annoying and unfunny comedy relief characters for every good character and it brings the whole show down. This season especially continues to see a trend of characters either part of the main cast or introduced primarily for comedic relief, and the quality of the writing simply not being competent enough to pull it off. Every moment of awe inspiring animation or heart tearing emotion is quickly contrasted with gags pulled out of a Naruto filler episode. The effect is tonal and enjoyment whiplash. This show made me care and cry for a brand new character in record ... |